Beyond Extension: Why the Extended Evolutionary Synthesis Demands a Paradigm Shift
The debate surrounding the Extended Evolutionary Synthesis (EES) is frequently framed as a simple, incremental update to the existing Modern Synthesis (MS). Proponents of this modern view often present the EES as a harmonious broadening of evolutionary theory, one that merely incorporates new empirical findings like epigenetic inheritance, phenotypic plasticity, developmental bias, and niche construction. However, a deeper conceptual examination reveals that the EES is not merely an additive extension. Instead, it represents a fundamental break from the foundational assumptions of the Modern Synthesis, introducing a distinct conceptual paradigm that redefines the primary units, vectors, and dynamics of biological evolution. To understand why the EES constitutes a paradigm shift rather than a minor upgrade, one must first examine the core differences between the two frameworks across four main dimensions: causation, inheritance, variation, and the role of the organism. First, the t...