Why Continuous Differential Equations Cannot Capture the Whole of Evolution
Classical population genetics built much of its mathematical machinery around differential equations. By treating allele frequencies as smooth, continuous variables changing over time in response to selection coefficients, mutation rates, and migration, early theorists gave evolutionary biology an elegant calculus of change. Yet when we ask whether differential equations can describe Darwinian evolution in its full biological reality, the answer is no. Differential equations excel at tracking gradual shifts in bookkeeper frequencies under fixed rules, but evolution is not merely a continuous change of rates on a static ledger. It is a history of novelty, non-linear thresholds, context-dependent phenotypes, and creative ecological and developmental interactions that repeatedly break the assumptions of smooth differential modeling. At the most basic level, differential equations assume continuity where biology is discrete, historical, and contingent. Genes are discrete packets of inform...