Posts

60 years of evolutionary theory challenged

Image
With all the new developments in genetics and especially epigenetics, I sometimes feel I practiced medicine with leeches for 30 years.  Advances in medicine have disproved the "practice" of leeches; maybe older evolutionary "practices" will also be disproved.  In June 2022, Nature journal published an article called "Synonymous mutations in representative yeast genes are mostly strongly non-neutral."  The authors claimed that 60 years of neo-darwinism, aka the modern synthesis, is challenged by declaring that most “silent” (synonymous) mutations were not neutral but harmful. The discovery of the genetic code in 1961 noted DNA had four nucleotides coding for only 20 amino acids that make up proteins.   Three-letter DNA units called "codons" code each of the 20 amino acids. DNA has 64 (3^4) codon combinations for 20 amino acids.  Figure codon table Why was this the case? Why a "redundant" 64 to 20 "code?"...

Cell differentiation is caused by Epigenetics without Darwin

Image
The human body, a marvel of biological engineering, comprises over 200 distinct cell types, each performing specialized functions crucial for life. This incredible cellular diversity arises not solely from the information encoded within our genes, but also from the dynamic interplay of epigenetics, a field that goes beyond the traditional neo-Darwinian framework. While neo-Darwinism focuses on genetic mutations and natural selection as the primary drivers of evolution, epigenetics reveals how gene expression can be modulated without altering the underlying DNA sequence, offering a deeper understanding of cellular differentiation and development. The human genome, the complete set of genetic instructions, provides the blueprint for building a human. However, this blueprint is not a rigid, pre-determined program. Instead, it is a flexible set of instructions that can be interpreted and executed differently depending on the context. This context is provided by the epigenome, a...

The Architecture of Life: How Hierarchical Evolutionary-Developmental Theory and Epigenetics Reframe Darwin

Image
A new perspective is challenging the long-held tenets of neo-Darwinism, offering a more integrated and multi-layered understanding of the evolutionary process. This emerging framework, known as Hierarchical Evolutionary-Developmental Theory (H-Evo-Devo), repositions the organism and its developmental processes at the heart of evolutionary change. By incorporating principles of hierarchy and the crucial role of epigenetics, this theory presents a significant challenge to the gene-centric view that has dominated evolutionary thought for nearly a century, proposing a more holistic and dynamic picture of how life diversifies and innovates. At its core, H-Evo-Devo theory posits that evolution operates on multiple, nested levels of biological organization, from the familiar microevolutionary changes within populations to the grander macroevolutionary and even "mega-evolutionary" patterns that shape the entire tree of life. This contrasts sharply with the traditional neo...

Epimutations Define a Fast-Ticking Molecular Clock in Plants

Image
The discovery that epimutations spontaneous,heritable changes in DNA methylation act as a fast-ticking molecular clock in plants represents a profound shift in our understanding of evolutionary timescales and inheritance. This "epimutation-clock" provides an unprecedented tool for studying evolutionary divergence over remarkably short periods, a scale largely inaccessible to traditional genetic methods. The core finding is that stochastic changes in DNA methylation at certain cytosine sites, particularly in CG dinucleotides, accumulate at a rate orders of magnitude faster than genetic mutations, yet remain sufficiently stable and neutral to serve as a reliable temporal marker. How Epigenetics Affects the Molecular Clock Epigenetics refers to heritable changes in gene function that occur without a change in the DNA sequence itself. The key epigenetic mechanism in the plant clock is DNA methylation, the addition of a methyl group to a cytosine base. Specifically, th...

Epigenetic Flexibility: How a Newly Formed Gene in Arabidopsis thaliana Challenges the Tenets of the Modern Synthesis

Image
The discovery of extensive natural epigenetic variation at a de novo originated gene, specifically the Qua-Quine Starch (QQS) gene in the plant Arabidopsis thaliana, provides compelling evidence for the dynamic role of epigenetics in evolution. This finding challenges the established framework of the Modern Evolutionary Synthesis by demonstrating a source of heritable variation that is not directly tied to changes in the DNA sequence, suggesting a more complex and flexible evolutionary mechanism, particularly for young genes. How Epigenetic Variation Affects the De Novo Gene The study focuses on the QQS gene, which is involved in starch metabolism and is believed to have originated de novo meaning it evolved from previously non-coding DNA relatively recently in the Arabidopsis lineage. The research reveals that the expression of the QQS gene varies significantly across natural Arabidopsis populations. Crucially, this expression variation is negatively correlated with the l...

De novo gene birth challenges Neo-Darwinism

Image
"How could all of these pieces fall into place through the random processes of mutation, recombination, and neutral drift—or at least enough of these pieces to produce a protogene that was sufficiently useful for selection to take hold? One can imagine a process by which short, simple genes periodically arise de novo, then gradually become more complex over time.” -Darwinian Alchemy De noo gene birth is the process where new genes arise from previously non-coding DNA sequences. These "newborn" genes can code for proteins or function as RNA genes. The exact mechanisms are unclear, but they may involve changes that create open reading frames (ORFs) or transcriptional activation. This process contributes to genetic novelty and can play a role in adaptation. Here are 10 ways in which de novo gene birth by Neo-Darwinism is improbable: De novo gene birth requires a large number of mutations to occur in a specific order. This is because a new gene must be created fr...

Phylo-Epigenetics in Phylogeny Analyses and Evolution: Re-evaluating the Mechanisms of Heredity and Evolutionary Change

Image
The journal article "Phylo-Epigenetics in Phylogeny Analyses and Evolution" delves into the critical, yet often overlooked, role of epigenetic inheritance in shaping evolutionary history and determining phylogenetic relationships. By focusing on a "phylo-epigenetic" approach, the research challenges the strictly gene-centric view of evolution championed by the Modern Synthesis, proposing that heritable non-genetic information significantly contributes to the diversity and evolutionary trajectories of species, particularly in mammals. The Involvement of Epigenetics Epigenetics refers to heritable changes in gene activity and expression that occur without altering the underlying DNA sequence.  These modifications act "on top of" the genetic code, determining which genes are active and which are silent, thereby shaping an organism's phenotype. The article specifically highlights the following mechanisms: DNA Methylation and CpG Dinucleotides ...